Devotion: The Gloriavale Story

Devotion: The Gloriavale Story (released internationally as Devotion: Obedience or Betrayal) is a three-part documentary series exploring the isolated and controversial Christian community of Gloriavale on the South Island of New Zealand. Directed and produced with rare inside access by Dame Julie Christie, the series contrasts decades of severe abuse scandals and legal convictions with interviews from current members defending their way of life.

About the series

Directed by Natalie Malcon and Justin Pemberton, the docuseries explores the immense physical and psychological battles individuals face when attempting to flee the isolated commune located on the West Coast of the South Island.

The series is structured across three episodes:

  • Episode 1: In Search of Truth — traces Gloriavale’s origins through founder Neville Cooper (known within the community as “Hopeful Christian”), and how a movement built on obedience and shared living gradually hardened into a system of control.
  • Episode 2: Sins of the Father — covers the police raid on the community and the founder’s fall from power.
  • Episode 3: The Choices We Make — follows the leadership crisis after the founder’s death, as Gloriavale’s new leadership faces continued scrutiny and allegations.

Unlike some earlier documentaries on Gloriavale, Devotion makes a point of including extended interviews with current members who defend the community and reject the “cult” label, alongside former members who describe a very different experience. The series doesn’t shy away from the community’s documented history of abuse: according to the series, at least 14 members of the community have been convicted of sexual or physical offending over the past 30 years.

Content warning: the series addresses sexual and physical abuse directly and in detail, along with the community’s patriarchal structure, arranged marriages, and strict control over members’ personal lives.

Devotion: The Gloriavale Story poster
A Closer Look

Beyond the Screen

Documentaries like Devotion: Obedience or Betrayal can be controversial and former members often have a lot to say after something like this airs. So what did they think? Unsolicited, more than twenty leavers connected with the GLST to express their thoughts about the doco, while others responded to media interviews. So we’ve captured their views and have categorised them below for your ease of reading. They show fascinating insight from people who are thoroughly familiar with the Gloriavale frame of thinking. What did they think? What was missing? What was whitewashed? Has Gloriavale changed enough? Was the doco balanced? What were the consistent themes that came across? And what do they want the doco makers to know?

“It was rare?! That is simply not true. Why are they trying to kid themselves?”

Quotes and Responses

Former members share their honest reactions to how their experiences were portrayed on screen

Themes Worth Examining

A closer look at the ideas the docuseries raises, the nuances it captures well, and the context it leaves out

Asking the Hard Questions

The questions we think the filmmakers still need to answer, and the choices behind what made the final cut

Related Articles

A collection of related articles, blog posts, reviews, and other information.